United States Tax Court March 29, 1963, Docket Nos. 87982, 93268 (Cuckler v. Commissioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-03-1963

lead-opinion

OPINION.

Murdock, Judge:

The principal question for decision in this case and the only question for decision in the Lacy case is whether the bank stock was sold to Lacy for $475,000, as Cuckler and Brown contend, or whether there was a sale of the bank stock for $375,000 and a sale by Cuckler, Brown & Co. of the bank building to Lacy for $100,000, as Lacy contends. The Commissioner has taxed a dividend to both resulting from a bargain sale of the bank building but concedes that only one tax is due. There is confusion because of the peculiar wording of the written contract of July 16, 1955. It is proper in tax cases to look through form to substance, if that is necessary, in order to determine the correct tax consequences of the acts of each taxpayer and those dealing with him in the transaction or transactions in dispute. Sarah Helen Harrison, 17 T.C. 1350. Cf. Helvering v. Lazarus & Co., 308 U.S. 252. Niceties of title or conveyancing should not hide the tax effects of whole transactions. Cf. Gregory v. Helvering, 293 U.S. 465; Griffiths v. Commissioner, 308 U.S. 355, 357; Rupe Investment Corporation v. Commissioner, 266 F. 2d 624, affirming 30 T.C. 240; Estate of Arthur L. Hobson, 17 T.C. 854.

Cuckler and Brown rely on Cuckler’s testimony in explanation and clarification of the written contract dated July 16,1955. Cuckler was called by the Commissioner and gave his testimony as the Commissioner’s witness. There was no objection to his testimony by any counsel in this case, all of whom seem to agree that the contract is ambiguous and parol evidence is proper. The Court agrees. See Walter Lacy, 39 T.C. 1100 (promulgated with this case). All counsel agreed that all testimony received during the trial of the related cases would apply in all of those cases. Lacy’s counsel objected to the admission of parol evidence and stated at the trial: “So far as Mr. Lacy is concerned he does not care to give the Court an explanation of the Contract before the Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.