United States Tax Court July 26, 1963, Docket No. 90647 (Frederic R. Harris, Inc. v. Commissioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1963

lead-opinion

OPINION

Raum, Judge:

In computing its excess profits credit for the taxable years petitioner corporation seeks to utilize the earnings experience of the decedent’s sole proprietorship during the base period years, 1946-49. To achieve that result, it argues that it should be classified as an “acquiring corporation” under section 461 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1939, as amended, or alternatively, as a “purchasing corporation” under section 474 of the Code, as amended. We think that it has failed to establish qualification under either of these provisions.

That portion of the statute (section 461(a) (1) (D)) upon which petitioner primarily relies defines an “acquiring corporation” to mean a “corporation which has acquired * * * substantially all the properties of a partnership [1] in an exchange to which section 112(b) (5) * * * is applicable.” (Italics supplied.) And, for its alternative contention, petitioner urges that it qualifies as a “purchasing corporation” under section 474, which defines that term to mean a corporation which, before December 1, 1950, acquired in a transaction other than one described in section 461(a) “substantially all of the properties (other than cash) * * * of a business owned by a sole proprietorship.” (Italics supplied.) Thus, neither of the foregoing sections would be applicable to petitioner unless it has shown that it acquired “substantially all” of the properties of Admiral Harris’ sole proprietorship,2 and we think it has failed to do so on this record.

We note at the outset, as stipulated by the parties, that “None of the assets reflected on the balance sheet of the sole proprietorship as of July 20, 1949 * * * was transferred to the petitioner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.