District Court of Appeal of Florida September 27, 1963, Nos. 3571, 3572 (Schulz v. City of Dania)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-09-1963
FUSSELL, CARROLL W., Associate Judge.
Defendant lot owners appeal from a final decree quieting the title of the plaintiff, City of Dania, and its assignee, to certain lands in Broward County. The defendants were the owners of lots in block 207, which was originally platted in 1924, at which time block 207 was bounded on the east by the Atlantic Ocean and on the west by a strip of land belonging to the plaintiff.
*521The court found that thereafter block 207 gradually disappeared by erosion and that th'e defendants’ lots no longer exist. The court thereupon decreed that the lands of the plaintiff, City of Dania, and its as-signee, were bounded on the east by the Atlantic Ocean, and by its decree vested in the plaintiff, and its assignee, all of the riparian rights incident to the ownership of their said lands.
The defendant-appellants question this finding of the court, contending that there is no preponderance of the evidence indicating that the land gradually disappeared by erosion, and that in fact the evidence is fully insufficient to determine whether or not the land disappeared by erosion or by avulsion. It is further the contention of the appellants that since the plaintiff instituted this suit the burden is on the plaintiff to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the land disappeared by erosion.
The difference between erosion and avulsion and the legal effect thereof upon the title, as well as the burden of proof in such matters, has been clearly stated by Judge Shannon of this court in the recent opinion of Municipal Liquidators, Inc. v. Robert R. Tench, etc., Fla.App., 153 So.2d 728:
“(1, 2) The chancellor reasoned in his opinion, and we think correctly, that erosion or submergence is accretion in reverse, and the imperceptible principle is applicable in distinguishing erosion from avulsion.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit