Circuit Court of the 13th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Hillsborough County January 17, 1963, Nos. 41363 and 41364 (Kaufman v. Eagle Roofing & Art Works)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-01-1963
OLIVER C. MAXWELL, Circuit Judge.
This cause came on on defendant’s motions to strike in both of the above cases. The first suit is an administrator’s suit under section 45.11 F. S. The second is a wrongful death action by a widow. Both motions seek to strike paragraph 5 of the respective complaints which, after the complaint had alleged a cause of action in an automobile collision under the doctrine of respondeat superior and dangerous instrumentality set up a paragraph alleging negligence in employment of the driver. This paragraph adds nothing to the cause of action, is irrelevant and immaterial and it is therefore, ordered and adjudged that said motions to strike paragraph 5 of both complaints are granted.
With respect to the administrator’s complaint, the defendant also seeks to strike claims for funeral expenses and for punitive damages. As to the claim for funeral expenses the defendant contends that under section 45.11 F. S. the administrator is entitled to recover only what the decedent could have recovered had he lived. The plaintiff cites two cases — Love v. Hannah (Fla. 1954), 72 So.2d 39, and Florida East Coast Railroad Co. v. Soper, (Fla. Third District 1962), 146 So.2d 605. The first case was an administrator’s suit under section 45.11 F. S. coupled with an action for wrongful death. The administrator’s suit alleged —
“ * * * and funeral expenses were incurred. In this connection plaintiffs further say that the estate became indebted for *26funeral home services in Miami, the cost of transporting deceased to Tallahassee, Florida, from Miami, Florida, and for funeral services in Tallahassee.”
A verdict for the plaintiffs was reversed because the verdict did not separate damages; the court concluded that the death action must be reversed and there was insufficient proof to support the amount of damages under the survival statute.
In the recent case of Florida East Coast Railroad Co. v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit