Circuit Court of the 4th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Duval County July 29, 1963, No. 63-3271-E (Hescom, Inc. v. Southern Bell Tel. & Tel. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-07-1963

TYRIE A. BOYER, Circuit Judge.

Order, July U, 1963: This cause came on to be heard on July 4, 1963 on the defendant’s motion to dismiss the complaint and the plaintiff’s prayer for an injunction restraining the defend*2ant from distributing the Jacksonville telephone directory which is to become effective July 14, 1963, a copy of which was received in evidence as defendant’s exhibit no. 1. (The plaintiff consented to the evidence being received out of order). At the commencement of the hearing the plaintiff moved ore tenus for permission to amend the prayer of its complaint, which motion was granted. It appears from the testimony adduced at the hearing that the telephone directory, the distribution of which is sought to be enjoined, contains many thousands of changes in telephone listings and many thousands of new numbers which are not listed in the directory now in use. It also appears that the directory contains advertising in the “yeH°w pages” for many persons and firms, which does not appear in the directory currently in use, and that such persons and firms have paid many thousands of dollars for such advertising. It further appears that a reprinting of the directory, the distribution of which is sought to be enjoined, would cost in excess of $150,000, and that such reprinting would require many days.

The plaintiff has not alleged, and does not contend, that the defendant has acted wilfully, wantonly or maliciously in the omission of the listing alleged in the complaint.

Upon consideration, the court finds that the interests of the general public, particularly the many thousands of persons and firms whose telephone listings will be changed or added in the new directory, the distribution of which is sought to be enjoined, would be so adversely affected that it would create an undue hardship upon the general public, as well as the defendant, to grant the injunction sought by the plaintiff and would therefore be inequitable.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.