Supreme Judicial Court of Maine February 20, 1963 (State v. Austin)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-02-1963

Siddall, J.

On exceptions. These cases involve two indictments against the defendant for cheating by false pretenses. In one, which for convenience we refer to herein as the first indictment, the State charged that the defendant represented that he “would deliver to the said Allen S. Menter a specified number of bank wallets with specified advertising thereon and all within a designated period of time.” The pretense charged in the second indictment was in the identical language except that the promise was alleged to have been made to one Myron A. Butler.

The first indictment charged the crime as having been committed on July 14, 1961, and the second indictment charged the crime as having been committed on December 28, 1961. The only significance in these dates is that by legislation effective on September 16, 1961, the statute under which the defendant was indicted was amended by adding thereto the following provision: “A promise, if unconditioned and made without present intention of performance, will constitute a false pretense within this section.” P. L. 1961, Chap. 40.

The rule is well established that in the absence of a statute authorizing a prosecution upon a promise made without a present intention of performance, a false pretense to be indictable must be an untrue statement of a past or an existing fact. A false pretense as to future acts or events will not support a conviction for obtaining property under false pretenses.

In the case of State v. Albee, 152 Me. 425, 429, 132 A. (2nd) 559, the court said: “If, as the respondent argues, the *73evidence is such that the statements made by the respondent, ‘. . . pertained to acts which the respondent was to do in the future and were not statements of present existing fact .....’no crime has been committed.” In an early case, State v. Mills, 17 Me.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.