California Court of Appeal November 4, 1963, Civ. No. 10611 (Scott v. Turpin)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-1963

VAN DYKE, J.*

This is an appeal from an order denying probate of a will in a contest tried before the court sitting without a jury.

The court made findings as follows: That when the will was made the testator was afflicted with senile dementia and was not competent to make a will; that the decedent was subject to irrational delusions and irrational fears with respect to his son and sole heir; and that the delusions and fears directly influenced the making and execution of the purported will. These findings are supported in the proof and therefore the order appealed from must be affirmed.

We state the evidence conformably to the rule governing reviews of factual findings. Decedent Richard N. Turpin died August 2, 1960, aged 83. He left a will dated May 27, 1960. Contestant Arthur R. Turpin, aged 60, was the only child of decedent who survived infancy. Petitioner Dixie Leona Scott was a niece of decedent, aged 70 years at the time of trial. The will specifically disinherited decedent’s son and willed his entire estate to appellant. Between decedent and appellant there had been no contact for over 50 years save for a few overnight visits a number of years prior to the making of the will. For many years contestant and his wife had lived on a ranch with decedent and contestant’s mother. There was a close family relationship. There was further an oral understanding at one time that the ranch would eventually go to contestant and his wife. Contestant's mother died in 1958. Thereafter personality and living habits of decedent underwent marked changes. He did not keep himself clean and urinated in his clothing; he wandered in his speech; he suffered a delusion that a man entered his house through a window that was in fact nailed shut. He talked of hiding money on the ranch, frequently changing the place of concealment and the amount concealed. He complained that the county treasurer withheld half his monthly old-age-pension checks.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.