Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 27, 1963 (Seneca Hotel Corp. v. Board of Supervisors)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1963

Halperh, J.

This proceeding is a sequel to Matter of Seneca Hotel Corp. v. Chacchia (13 A D 2d 896, affd. 10 N Y 2d 1031). In that ease, we modified an order reducing the assessment on the petitioner’s property and affirmed the order as modified. The order as affirmed provided: “ 5. That the Common Council of the City of Geneva, New York at the next budget or other appropriate meeting following entry of this order shall audit, allow and pay to petitioner that part of the taxes representing city tax for the year 1960 and school tax for year 1959-1960 and being in excess of what such tax would have been if the assessment complained of had been as herein ordered and determined, together with interest thereon at three percent (3%) from the date of payment as provided in Real Property Tax Law, Sec. 726 ”. The order further provided in paragraph 6 that the Board of Supervisors of Ontario County should take similar action with respect to “ that part of the taxes representing state and county tax for the year 1960

The city repaid its part of the excess or erroneous tax pursuant to the order, after affirmance by the Court of Appeals, but the county refused to refund its part. This proceeding was thereupon brought to compel the county to make the necessary refund but the petition was dismissed at Special Term upon the ground that it was the duty of the city to make the entire refund of the tax erroneously collected, including that portion representing county taxes.

We are met at the threshold by the claim of the appellant that the order in the tax certiorari proceeding constituted a final adjudication which is binding upon the county, under the principle of res judicata. This is undoubtedly true insofar as the portion of the order reducing the assessment is concerned. Since *185the county made no assessments of its own but used the assessments made by the City Assessors, the City Assessors were the only necessary parties to the tax certiorari proceeding.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.