Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 3, 1963 (Onofrio v. Playboy Club of New York, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-12-1963
lead-opinion
Botein, P. J.
This is an appeal from an order granting the major portion of the relief sought by defendant-respondent’s motion to dismiss each of two causes of action contained in a consolidated amended complaint asserting a class action on behalf of a large number of alleged members of defendant club.
The first cause of action seeks to impress a constructive trust upon and secure an accounting for a large fund created through individual contributions made by the members of the club; and plaintiffs claim that such members, as beneficiaries of the resulting constructive trust, can maintain a class action. This cause of action was properly dismissed, since plaintiffs do not claim fraud, merely breach of an agreement, and there does not appear to have been any confidential relationship between the parties (Cassidy v. Cassidy, 309 N. Y. 332; Peppard Realty Co. v. Emdon, 204 App. Div. 8). Furthermore, plaintiffs have an adequate remedy at law, as will be indicated.
*5Special Term granted that branch of the motion addressed to the second canse of action, which alleged breach of the numerous contracts entered into between the members of the class and defendant, to the extent of holding that this cause of action may not be maintained by the named plaintiffs as representatives of a class, but that each of them should separately state and number his cánse of action.
In such cases as Brenner v. Title Guar. & Trust Co. (276 N. Y. 230), Society Milion Athena v. National Bank of Greece (281 N. Y. 282), Kahlmeyer v. Green-Wood Cemetery (287 N. Y. 787) and Noel Holding Corp. v. Carvel Dari-Freeze Stores (140 N. Y. S. 2d 640, affd. 286 App. Div. 1066), a thread runs from the defendant to each member of the putative class but none operates as a common binding among the members themselves. That is not the instant pattern.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit