New York Supreme Court January 24, 1963 (St. Clare's Hospital v. Breslin)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-01-1963

Isadore Bookstein, J.

Petitioner instituted this proceeding to review a determination of the Albany County Welfare Commissioner denying payment of two hospital bills for one Pearl Schoonmaker, an alleged medically indigent person and to compel payment thereof.

Respondent served no answer to the petition. Instead, he served an affidavit. In this posture, Special Term dismissed the petition. (27 Misc 2d 126.)

An appeal was taken from the Special Term order of dismissal to the Appellate Division which reversed the Special Term order on procedural grounds, since no answer was served and gave leave to respondent to serve an answer, which was subsequently done. (14 A D 2d 380.)

In its opinion for reversal, the Appellate Division said (p. 382): “If, however, we were to consider the merits, the order would likewise have to be reversed. ’ ’

After the answer was served, petitioner made a motion for summary judgment. Special Term denied that motion on the ground that there remained a triable issue of fact as to whether or not Pearl Schoonmaker, hereinafter referred to as “ Pearl ”, was a “ medically indigent ” person and made an order for that single issue to be tried at Trial Term and that issue has now been tried.

It is clear that there is no factual dispute, except as to the sole issue thus tried.

“Pearl” was admitted to the hospital of petitioner as an emergency patient on two occasions, viz., on June 25, 1960 and on July 23, 1960. Because of the emergencies, there was no prior authorization for her admission by respondent on either occasion. The charge for the first admission was $393 and for the second admission, $675.36, or a total of $1,068.36, for which amount petitioner seeks payment from respondent.

In compliance with section 187 (subd. 2, par. [c]) of the Social Welfare Law, petitioner gave due and timely notice of the emergency admissions of “ Pearl” as a medically indigent person, and that it looked to respondent for payment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.