New York Supreme Court April 16, 1963 (Wyatt v. Fulrath)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-04-1963

Owest McGivern, J.

This action presents for determination the title to personal property as between the estate of a Spanish husband, the Duke of Arion and the estate of his wife, the Duchess of Arion. The action is brought by Inzer B. Wyatt, Esq., as ancillary administrator c. t. a. of the Dulce of Arion against Logan Fulrath, Esq., as executor of the duchess and three banks, involving securities and cash in custody accounts maintained by the duke and the duchess with the banks in New York City.

This court’s jurisdiction of the action is established by the decision of the Appellate Division herein (13 A D 2d 250 [1961]) reversing an order (26 Misc 2d 554) dismissing the complaint upon the ground that plaintiff’s claims should be adjudicated in the Surrogate’s Court. The opinion of the Appellate Division, however, in no way considered the merits of this controversy.

The principal claim of the plaintiff Wyatt is that the duke and the duchess were domiciliaries of Spain, that Spanish law governs the rights of their representatives to the property in question and that under Spanish law (a) all property, with certain exceptions, owned by husband and wife, or either of them, constitutes community property, (b) on the death of a spouse half of all community property immediately vests in the surviving spouse and the other half in the estate of the deceased spouse, and (c) no agreement, gift between husband and wife or other transaction can lawfully vary the foregoing legal principles. Accordingly, the plaintiff seeks a declaration that half of each account vested in the duke’s estate upon his death in 1957, prior to the death of the duchess, which latter event occurred in 1959.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.