New York County Courts May 17, 1963 (People v. Gardner)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-05-1963

Jerome B. E. Wolff, J.

The defendant and others were charged by an indictment for the following crimes:

First count, robbery, first degree, in violation of sections 2, 2120 and subdivision 2 of section 2124 of the Penal Law; second count, robbery, first degree, in violation of section 2120 and subdivision 4 of section 2124; third count, burglary, third degree; fourth count, grand larceny, second degree; fifth count, assault in the second degree, subdivision 3 of section 242.

On November 20, 1961, Lester Gardner, the defendant and petitioner on this motion, entered a plea of guilty to the fourth *158count of the indictment alleging grand larceny, second degree, in violation of sections 1290 and 1296 of the Penal Law, and entered a plea of guilty to the fifth count of the indictment of assault in the second degree in violation of subdivision 3 of section 242 of the Penal Law of the State of New York, and was sentenced for an indeterminate term of a minimum of two and one-half years and a maximum term of five years on each count, both sentences to run consecutively.

The defendant on his motion contends that the two crimes for which he was sentenced arose from the same transaction or incident and therefore the consecutive sentences imposed upon him were violative of section 1938 of the Penal Law.

Since the defendant pleaded to the indictment, the court has had to resort to the probation report and the minutes of the Grand Jury in order to ascertain what the circumstances were surrounding the commission of the two crimes. The facts are succinctly stated as follows:

The defendant was in the apartment of a Thomas Sullivan, when an altercation took place between the defendant and the complainant. This assault had terminated, when a few moments later, the two codefendants entered the apartment and then all three defendants proceeded to brutally beat the victim for a prolonged period in order to force him to disclose the location where he kept his money hidden.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.