New York County Courts May 17, 1963 (People v. Cordello)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-05-1963

Jerome B. E. Wolff, J.

The defendant herein, on a plea of guilty to the crime of grand larceny in the second degree was sentenced on the 26th day of June, 1952, to the Reception Center at Elmira, New York.

The defendant contends in his moving papers that the theft of the automobile for which he was indicted was in value of less than $100 and that there was illegal, false and/or perjured testimony in reference to the value of the said automobile; and therefore the indictment charging him with grand larceny in the second degree and his conviction after a plea of guilty to gr'and larceny in the second degree is illegal and should be set aside.

In the indictment it was alleged that the defendant stole and appropriated to his own use a 1941 Plymouth sedan automobile of the value of $300. At the hearing the defendant produced two automobile dealers of long standing who testified in essence that a 1941 Plymouth sedan in the year 1952 was of value at most in the sum of $75 market value, if it was in excellent condition.

There was no proof at the hearing that there was any perjured or false testimony given by the witnesses brought before the Grand Jury or that if there wias, it was not brought to the attention of the District Attorney, therefore this court will not consider that part of the petition alleging perjured or false testimony.

A perusal of the Grand Jury minutes discloses that the evidence taken as to the value of the automobile was through a witness who drove the automobile which was registered in his mother’s name, who stated that he 'obtained the sum of $50 as a trade-in toward the purchase of a new automobile, and *161that in addition to that sum, the insurance company, which held the policy on the said car, paid the sum of $250 under the said policy. With this evidence the Grand Jury handed down an indictment which alleged that the automobile stolen by the defendant was of the value of $300.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.