New York Court of Claims August 2, 1963, Claim No. 39394; Claim No. 40255 (Caldwell v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-08-1963

J. Seward Bodies, J.

These two claims, which were tried together at a Special Term held in Canton, New York, commencing April 1, 1963, are to recover from the State for the wrongful deaths of Michael Caldwell and Francis Cole, employees of the Ingalls Construction Company. Ingalls was the steel fabricator and erector on a subcontract on a general contract awarded by the State to the G-iibane Building Company. The portion of the contract involved here called for the erection of two bridges of the suspended cantilever type over the Racquette River on the St. Regis Indian Reservation, both over 700 feet in length.

The claims are based upon the alleged negligence of the State in supervising the erection of the bridges and especially in failing to foresee the inadequacy of a temporary splice in a flexible joint in the steel girders of the eastbound bridge. During the erection of the steel, Ingalls deemed it necessary to make this flexible joint rigid by welding angle iron braces and steel beams to the main girders. The two members of the bridge as thus joined were hoisted by a crane into place and remained in place, without any indication of any collapse, for a period of more than 24 hours. When the temporary joint failed, without any warning, the bridge collapsed and Cole and Caldwell were carried to their deaths.

The State had two engineers on location, to wit: one Martin Hodges, who was a licensed professional engineer, and his assistant, William Turner, a civil engineer. From their testimony it appears that their duties consisted of inspecting the work as it progressed to insure that the contractors complied with the specifications. They gave no direct orders to the contractors or their employees, nor did they attempt to exercise any control over the methods used.

The claimants contend that section 53 .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.