New York Supreme Court July 30, 1963 (Lalli v. McCaffrey)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-07-1963

Frank S. McCullough, J.

This is a motion for summary judgment in an action for replevin. The plaintiff alleges that he is the rightful owner of a large sum of money which is presently in the custody of the Chief of Police of the City of New Rochelle, who is named as codefendant with the District Attorney of Westchester County.

It appears that on April 14,1963 information came to the attention of the District Attorney’s office that a 16-year-old boy and three younger boys had entered the cellar of a private home in New Rochelle on April 5, 1963 and removed a metal container containing approximately $60,000. The money was soon recovered and was turned over to the defendant Police Chief since the alleged burglary occurred in the City of New Rochelle. After the information with respect to the theft had been communicated to the authorities by one of the alleged offenders, police officers of the New Rochelle Police Department, together with an Assistant District Attorney, visited the home which was the scene of the theft to inquire about the money and the alleged burglary. The home is owned by one Mario Lalli. At the time the police called, according to the affidavit of an Assistant District Attorney, the plaintiff William Lalli was in the house. He informed the authorities that he was the son of Mario Lalli, that he was married and lived in an apartment in the City of Yonkers with his wife and child, and that he was the owner of the moneys that were stolen.

In his affidavit in support of the motion the plaintiff alleges the following:

‘‘ With the remains of a cash wedding present from my father, I gambled on the horses at Yonkers Raceway during the last *990couple of months, was lucky, and won a substantial amount of money.

‘11 accumulated $63,100.00 and I placed this money, in $100 bills, $50 bills and $20 bills in a tin box which I hid in the cellar of my parents’ home at 135 Daisy Farms Road.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.