New York Supreme Court August 23, 1963 (Faber v. Sweet Style Manufacturing Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-08-1963

Bernard S. Meyer, J.

The relationship of psychiatry to the criminal law has been the subject of study and recommendation by the Temporary Commission on Revision of the Penal Law and Criminal Code (Leg. Doe. [1963], No. 8, pp. 16-26). This court had reason to touch upon the relationship of psychiatry *213to matrimonial law in Anonymous v. Anonymous (37 Misc 2d 773). The instant case presents yet a third aspect of the same basic problem: that involving the law of contract.

Plaintiff herein seeks rescission of a contract for the purchase of vacant land in Long Beach on the ground that he was not at the time the contract was entered into of sufficient mental competence. Defendant counterclaims for specific performance.

The evidence demonstrates that from April until July, 1961, plaintiff was in the depressed phase of a manic-depressive psychosis and that from August until the end of October he was in the manic stage. Though under care of Dr. Levine, a psychiatrist, beginning June 8 for his depression, he cancelled his August 8 appointment and refused to see the doctor further. Previously frugal and cautious, he became more expansive beginning in August, began to drive at high speeds, to take his wife out to dinner, to be sexually more active and to discuss his prowess with others. In a short period of time, he purchased three expensive cars for himself, his son and his daughter, began to discuss converting his Long Beach bathhouse and garage property into a 12-story co-operative and put up a sign to that effect, and to discuss the purchase of land in Brentwood for the erection of houses. In September, against the advice of his lawyer, he contracted for land at "White Lake in the Catskills costing $11,500 and gave a $500 deposit on acreage, the price of which was $41,000 and talked about erecting a 400-room hotel with marina and golf course on the land.

On September 16, 1961, he discussed with Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.