Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York September 12, 1963 (Swarth v. Barney's Clothes, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-09-1963
Samuel H. Hoestadter, J.
The plaintiff sued in the Small Claims Court for $350 for the loss of a wallet claimed to have been left in her automobile while parked in the defendant’s parking lot. The defendant, Barney’s Clothes, Inc., maintains the lot for the free use of its patrons. The plaintiff testified that she had $350 in cash in the wallet when she left her home, had removed the wallet from her purse only to pay a toll, and, in attempting to replace it, inadvertently left it on the seat of the car. On the request of the parking lot attendant, she left the keys with him after locking the car. It is not claimed that the plaintiff informed the attendant when she parked the car *424with him that she had left her wallet on the’ seat. Indeed, she testified that when she left the keys with him she did not even know the wallet was in the car. There is thus a complete absence of notice to the defendant of the presence of the wallet in the car, much less the value of its contents. The attendant unlocked the car and left the keys in the ignition.
On the completion of her shopping in the defendant’s store an hour later the plaintiff missed her wallet and immediately returned to the car. A search of the car and subsequent search by the police of the attendant failed to yield the wallet. The plaintiff charges the defendant with negligence and recovered below.
When the defendant accepted the plaintiff’s automobile for parking, it unquestionably became its bailee and assumed the liability flowing from that relation. It by no means follows, however, that it thereby also undertook the bailment of the wallet, whose presence in the vehicle was neither disclosed nor reasonably to be expected. Delivery, actual or constructive, to the person sought to be held as bailee is not enough to create a bailment; acceptance, actually or constructively, by the latter is equally essential. (Osborn v. Cline, 263 N. Y. 434, 437; Cowen v. Pressprich, 202 App. Div. 796, revg.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit