New York Supreme Court October 3, 1963 (In re the Arbitration between Danza & Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-10-1963

Joseph A. Brvst, J.

This court on its own motion is recalling its decision in this matter which appeared in the New York Law Journal on September 29, 1963, and this matter is disposed of as follows:

Motion to stay arbitration. No issue is presented as to whether or not the petitioner’s injuries were caused by collision with an uninsured vehicle. The fact of disclaimer is not in dispute. The moving affidavit states that the 1 ‘ ‘ Atlantic National ’ * * * on or about November 8, 1962 disclaimed *777coverage to their insured, * * * for the accident of July 14,1960.”

“ Where the fact of disclaimer is in dispute, arbitration should be stayed pending an adjudication of that fact by a court of competent jurisdiction after hearing * * * But no such dispute is here presented * * * Since there is no requirement in the statute * * # the disclaimer be a valid one, we reject petitioner’s contention that, as a condition precedent to arbitration, the insured must first obtain a judicial determination of the right of the insurer of the motorist allegedly responsible for the accident to disclaim liability ” (Matter of MVAIC [Malone], 19 A D 2d 542, 543). At the time of this court’s original decision this court incorrectly believed the Malone case to be the law only in the Second Department. However, this no longer is true and the rule set forth in the Malone case is now also the law in the First Department as a result of Matter of Scire (MVAIC) (19 A D 2d 788).

In the Scire case the claimant filed a claim with the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation, after the company insuring the allegedly responsible motorist disclaimed liability. The claimant served a demand for arbitration, and the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation moved to vacate the demand on the ground that the question of insurance coverage was not an arbitrable issue. Special Term ordered a hearing or trial of ‘ ‘ the issues of insurance coverage and alleged disclaimer”.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.