New York Supreme Court November 4, 1963 (People v. Bjornsen)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-11-1963

Abraham (teller, J.

By this coram nobis application defendant seeks to be resenteneed nunc pro tunc so that he may now file a timely notice of appeal from his 1952 conviction. The basis for the relief sought is that, during the 30-day period- following his conviction, he asked a friend to speak to his court-assigned counsel “ about an appeal ” and that she was told that “ there was very little chance of success in the matter.” No appeal was then taken.

*987Defendant is obviously endeavoring to make this belated claim in reliance upon recent decisions holding that such relief may be granted where a defendant is prevented from complying with the statutory requirements for taking an appeal; such as People v. Hill (8 N Y 2d 935) where the ground was insanity during the statutory period for an appeal, and People v. Hairston (10 N Y 2d 92) where prison authorities prevented the taking of an appeal. In the Fourth Department it has been held (People v. Coe, 16 A D 2d 876) that an appeal may be deemed to have been “prevented” by act of assigned counsel in allegedly misinforming defendant that appeal was impossible because of lack of funds for trial transcript and printing of record. However, in the Second Department it has been held that failure to file a notice of appeal as allegedly agreed either by retained counsel (People v. Marchese, 19 A D 2d 728) or by court-appointed trial counsel, who for such purposes should be regarded as in effect retained counsel (People v. Kling, 19 A D 2d 750), is not a sufficient ground to warrant extraordinary relief amounting to an extension of time to appeal.

The ground here asserted, even assuming the truth thereof, falls far short of an act preventing the taking of an appeal. The functions of counsel assigned by the trial court terminate with the rendition of judgment and do not extend to the appeal process, for which the appellate court alone is empowered to assign counsel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.