Supreme Court of North Carolina November 20, 1963 (Spain v. Spain)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-11-1963

RodmaN, J.

As said by Shakp, J., in Trust Co. v. Bryant, 258 N.C. 482, 128 S.E. 2d 758: “The basic rule of -construction, and the refrain of every opinion; which seeks to comprehend a testamentary plan is that '(t)'he intent of the testator is the polar star that must guide the courts in the interpretation of a will’.” Moose, J., .said in Poindexter v. Trust Co., 258 N.C. 371, 128 S.E. 2d 167: “The intent of the testatrix iis her will and must ibe carried out unless some rule of law forbidis it.”

Testatrix did not “give,” “¡bequeath,” or “devise” 'her property. She “wants” (used .in nine different places) certain designated persons to have designated parts of her estate. Except where she expressly “wants” a beneficiary to have .a life estate in her realty, the will does not particularize ¡the estate the beneficiary acquires.

It is, we -think, apparent from the writing that Mrs. Wilson intended a complete disposition of her properties. Where one undertakes to make a will, the presumption is that toe instrument disposes oif all of testator’s property, not leaving a residue to pass under laws governing intestacy. Poindexter v. Trust Co., supra; Little v. Trust Co., 252 N.C. 229, 113 S.E. 2d 689. “Having undertaken to make a -will -at all, it is not consistent with sound reasoning that the testator would have left his estate -dangling.” Coddington v. Stone, 217 N.C. 714, 9 S.E. 2d 420.

Here toe intent -of -toe testatrix to limit the estate in toe realty given her brother Frank is -apparent. At -hie death she w-an-ts toe place to go to three named -nephews -and a great-nephew. Had toe will stopped *485there, the named devisees would ihiave taken an estate in fee. G.S. 31-38; Morris v. Morris, 246 N.C. 314, 98 S.E. 2d 298. But the will did not stop with 'the gift to the nephews and great-nephew who take on the termination of the life estate given to testatrix’ brother Frank. She said: “At there death I want the place to go to there 'Children & so on . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.