Ohio Court of Appeals March 7, 1963, No. 26076 (Morgan v. Sheppard)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-03-1963

Corrigan, J.

This cause is before the court on an appeal on questions of law from a jury verdict and judgment entered thereon in the Common Pleas Court of Cuyahoga County in the amount of $50,000.00 against a defendant, Dr. Stephen A. Sheppard, for wrongful death in a malpractice action. The plaintiff’s case went to the jury against Dr. Stephen A. Sheppard and two other defendants, Dr. Richard N. Sheppard and Bay View *581Hospital (Cleveland Osteopathic Hospital), and the verdict of the jury was in favor of each of the other two defendants.

A companion case for pain and suffering of the plaintiff’s decedent was tried at the same time against the same three defendants and resulted in verdicts for all defendants.

It seems advisable to set out at some length excerpts from the evidence that was before the jury as reflected by the voluminous record of 2260 pages and numerous exhibits. On June 12, 1956, plaintiff’s decedent, Harold W. Morgan, a 40 year old male, married, with three children, consulted Dr. Urwin W. Hampton, an osteopath, at the latter’s office in Berea, Ohio. Mr. Morgan complained of pain in his right mid chest and under the right lower ribs and further complained of trouble with his stomach for three or four years. Mr. Morgan stated to Dr. Hampton that three years before he had X-rays taken at Southwest Community Hospital in Berea, with diagnosis of an ulcer and was treated as an ulcer patient and that he got better; that the present pain did not seem the same and that it was not relieved by milk or food; that the pain was light and dull in nature and had lasted constantly for the past ten days; that he had trouble with greasy-food digestion; and that he had bowel trouble all of his life, but that he did not take cathartics regularly.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.