Ohio Court of Appeals July 10, 1963, No. 335 (Cummings Bank Co. v. Turner)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-07-1963
France, J.
This cause is before us ou a law and fact appeal from decree of Common Pleas Court, Carroll County, and was submitted on the original pleadings and exhibits, together with bill of exceptions used as a transcript of testimony.
On March 15, 1960, plaintiff financed the purchase by defendant Turner of a Lorain shovel to be used in a strip mining operation, taking a purchase money note and chattel mortgage on the shovel “together with all attachments and equipment, including such as may be added or substituted by the mortgagor.” The seller took at the time a subordinated chattel mortgage for the balance due him. Both mortgages were properly filed.
The Waukesha engine which was original equipment on the shovel became defective and after attempted repairs became completely inoperative, wherupon Turner purchased from defendant Cummins Diesel (hereinafter called Cummins) a more powerful replacement engine. About June 15, 1960, without foreknowledge or consent of plaintiff, the Waukesha engine and certain fittings were removed from the shovel, taken by Cummins to its shop and the fittings altered for application to the new engine. The new engine and fittings were then installed on the shovel at its operational site. Cummins, in payment of the purchase money and with both actual and constructive knowledge of plaintiff’s mortgage, took a single chattel mortgage from Turner Coal Co., John R. Turner, President, on an Osgood shovel and the Lorain shovel, “above Lorain shovel powered by Cummins Diesel Engine, Model NHRS 6-IP Serial No. 129537, with Cotta transmission * * *.”
The Waukesha engine was left at Cummins’ shop until its sale by Turner and delivery as scrap to a purchaser. The Lorain shovel was put to use on the site by Turner.
Turner thereafter defaulted on his stipulated payments to all mortgagees.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit