Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit January 23, 1963, No. 8739 (Haywood v. Gill)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-01-1963
BUTZNER, District Judge.
The sole question presented by this appeal is the determination of the date of acquisition of real estate for the purpose of computing capital gains resulting from its sale. The taxpayer’s1 father, Atlas M. Rigsbee, died testate in 1903. He devised the real estate to Sallie A. Rigs-bee, for life with remainder in fee, on failure of issue, to the taxpayer and other surviving children.
The District Court decided that the taxpayer acquired the property in 1903 when the testator died. The taxpayer urges that the date of acquisition was 1945 when the life tenant died.
At the time of Atlas M. Rigsbee’s death in 1903 the land had tenant houses upon it. In 1925 Sallie A. Rigsbee leased a portion of the real estate devised to her as life tenant. The lessees improved the land by erecting tobacco warehouses on it. Under the terms of the lease, all improvements placed upon the land were to remain the property of the lessees and were to be removable by them. From time to time Sallie A. Rigsbee executed renewal leases which contained the same provision. Such a lease was in effect at the time of her death.
Upon another portion of the land Sallie A. Rigsbee erected a drugstore in 1939 at her own expense.
Sallie A. Rigsbee died in 1945 and the taxpayer and other remaindermen came into possession of the real estate. Thereafter the taxpayer brought suit against the other remaindermen for partition of the real estate. The lessees of the property intervened to seek removal of the tobacco warehouses which they had erected. The Supreme Court of North Carolina held that the taxpayer and other remaindermen were entitled to the warehouses and that the lessees could not remove them. Haywood v. Briggs, 227 N. C. 108, 41 S.E.2d 289 (1947).
The drugstore property was sold in 1946 and the warehouse property in 1947. The taxpayer reported for these years the capital gains that she received upon her share of the proceeds from the sale of the properties.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit