Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit March 7, 1963, No. 13988 (Kline v. S. M. Flickinger Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-03-1963
GANEY, Circuit Judge.
The question raised on this appeal is whether the trial court committed reversible error in restricting the issue of negligence at the trial to the condition of the threshold strip of the entrance to a grocery store.
On August 31, 1958, at 5:15 p. m., the wife-plaintiff entered the Red and White retail grocery supermarket in Galeton, Pennsylvania. After she had made a purchase and was in the process of leaving the store through the same entrance that she had come in, she fell forward out the doorway on to the concrete landing which was 3% inches below the floor level of the store.1 Her grandson had preceded her in leaving the store and was holding one of the doors, which swung outward open for her.
The entrance was a single opening with two 3 by 7 feet glass panel doors, which swung in opposite directions. The floor had a checkered design and its coloring was different from the outside concrete. The threshold strip was made of metal and extended the length of the doorway opening and covered the entire concrete doorsill, being even with the outside edge thereof, and was fastened to the concrete doorsill by means of screws being inserted into the concrete. Inside the store the strip was beveled to meet the floor and fastened with countersunk screws.
The plaintiffs, husband and wife, brought their action on October 16, 1959, against S. M. Flickinger Co., Inc., and Super-Duper, Inc. Paragraph 6 of the complaint avers: “On August 31, 1958, at 5 P.M. * * * by reason of defendants’ defective installation or defective maintenance of the sill of the threshold the wife-plaintiff’s heel caught upon a defective protuberance at the sill portion of the threshold causing the wife-plaintiff to fall violently forward to the outside concrete landing of the store premises * * * ”
On August 2, 1960, plaintiffs amended their complaint to include as an additional defendant, Louis Greco, who had been brought on the record as a third-party defendant.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit