Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit December 23, 1963, No. 14272 (In re Howard)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-12-1963

HASTIE, Circuit Judge.

To facilitate an inquiry into a taxpayer’s possible persisting income tax liability, special agent William Ankron of the Internal Revenue Service, acting under authority of section 7602 of the 1954 Internal Revenue Code, signed and served on John Howard an administrative summons, requiring him to appear before Ankron at a stipulated time and place and to produce his business records and accounts for a period of four years, three of which were “closed years” in that the normal three-year statute of limitations had run against the assessment of tax deficiencies. Howard then filed as an original pleading in the district court this “Application to Quash” the administrative summons. He named no defendant and did not request that process be issued against anyone. In some manner the United States Attorney and special agent Ankron were notified of this filing and the United States Attorney filed a responsive pleading in behalf of the United States, both challenging the jurisdiction of the court and asserting that on the merits the summons was valid and enforceable. The district court found the proceeding a proper one and, on the merits, ordered the administrative summons quashed as to the closed years. The United States has appealed.

On its merits this controversy involves a number of considerations that are discussed in an opinion we have filed today in United States v. Powell, 3 Cir., 325 F.2d 914. However, in this case we are unable to reach the merits.

Rules 2, 3, 8 and 10 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure restrict original civil proceedings1 in a district court to a single form of action, commenced by a complaint naming the parties, stating the basis of the court’s jurisdiction and demanding specified relief against someone.

The application which instituted this original civil proceeding is deficient in all of these respects. It names no defendant, states no basis of jurisdiction and asks for no judgment against anyone.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.