Indiana Court of Appeals March 18, 1963, No. 19,433 (Stadium Realty Co. v. Bill Anderson Spring Service, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-03-1963

Clements, J.

Upon request of appellant oral argument in this case was set for January 31, 1963. On January 22, 1963, a joint petition was filed by appellant and appellee asking that the oral argument be waived and this cause submitted for determination upon the briefs, and an order was entered accordingly.

Rule 2-17 (e) of the Supreme Court provides, in pertinent part, as follows:

“(e) The brief shall contain under the heading ‘Argument’ a specification of such of the assigned errors as are intended to be urged, and each cause in the motion for a new trial which is intended to be urged. After each assignment of error relied upon — except the ruling on a *385motion for a new trial, and after each cause for a new trial relied upon, there shall be concisely-stated the basis of the objection to the ruling complained of, exhibiting clearly the points of fact and of law being presented, and how they are applicable, citing the authorities and statutes relied upon, and setting out verbatim the relevant parts of such statutes as are deemed to have an important bearing.”

The argument portion of appellant’s brief sets forth • arguments and propositions of law, but sets forth very little authority, and completely fails to apply such propositions of law to the facts in issue under the assigned errors. This constitutes a waiver of the claimed error. Poore v. Poore (1955), 125 Ind. App. 392, 125 N. E. 2d 810.

As stated in Ecker v. Fuchs (1959), 129 Ind. App. 555, at page 566, 159 N. E. 2d 134, at page 139:

“Appellant’s argument in this case does not ‘affirmatively’ show harmful error but simply casts before this court certain general contentions and abstract and incomplete legal pronouncements, with the apparent expectation that the court will rummage through the evidence and the decree of the trial court in quest of a suggested ground or reason for reversal of that court’s determination of the action.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.