Supreme Court of Iowa July 16, 1963, No. 51035 (Board of Education ex rel. Essex Independent School District v. Board of Education ex rel. Montgomery County)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-1963

Moore, J.

For the second time we consider rulings of the State Department of Public Instruction on the petition for reorganization of certain districts in Page and Montgomery Counties into the Coburg-Essex Community School District. Our first opinion (Board of Education v. Board of Education, 251 Iowa 1085, 104 N.W.2d 590) reversed the trial court’s approval of the state department’s order vacating the decision of the joint boards of Page and Montgomery Counties. We held the state department had not given proper notice of hearing to all interested school districts, remanded the case and ordered it sent back to the state board for proper action.

Thereafter on proper notice a hearing on the controversy presented was held. The state board vacated the decision and order of the joint boards approving the petition for reorganization.

From this ruling the board of the Essex Independent School District and the board of the Coburg Consolidated School District appealed to the district court of Page County.

The trial court sustained the action of the state board. Plaintiffs have appealed.

May 12, 1958, there was filed with the Page County school superintendent, pursuant to section 275.12 (all references are to Code of 1958), a petition for the reorganization of 21 existing districts in Page and Montgomery Counties into the Coburg-*539Essex Community School District. The proposed area consisted of approximately 33 sections of land in Montgomery County and 87 in Page with an estimated value of $6,600,000 and included 550 pupils. The boundaries proposed did not conform to the established Montgomery County school plans nor those of Page County. The petition requested changes of each. This was the second proposal for the establishment of the Coburg-Essex Community School District. The first, consisting of a slightly larger area, was filed January 20, 1958. After hearing many objections the joint boards dismissed that proposal. On appeal the state board affirmed that dismissal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.