Mississippi Supreme Court December 20, 1963, No. 42824 (Mabry v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-12-1963
McGeheb, C. J.
Percy N. Mabry, Calvin Sullivan and William Gordon Sullivan were indicted, tried and convicted on a charge of burglary in the Circuit Court of Grenada County, and were each sentenced to serve a term of three years in the state penitentiary.
The case must be reversed because of errors in the instructions obtained on behalf of the State. There were several instructions granted in the case but in none of them was the crime of burglary defined. Three of the State’s instructions were in identical language, and they *151pertained separately to each, of the defendants. The instruction obtained by the State in the case of Percy N. Mabry is as follows: ‘ ‘ The Court instructs the jury for the State that if you believe from the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant, Percy Mabry, is guilty as charged in the indictment, then it is your sworn duty to so find, and the form of your verdict will be: ‘We the jury find the defendant Percy N. Mabry guilty as charged.’ ”
The same instruction as to each of the other defendants, except as to the name of the accused, is in the same language. It is to be noted that this instruction, as well as the instructions for the State in the cases against the two Sullivans, did not define the crime. They simply stated that, “if the jury believed the defendant was guilty as charged in the indictment, then the jury should so find.” In civil cases involving a charge of negligence, it is well established that instructions for the plaintiff must state the alleged acts of negligence and define them, and may not simply refer to the negligence as charged in the declaration. In criminal cases such a requirement should be even stronger and more necessary. This is the general rule. The jury should be instructed properly as to the nature and elements of the offense charged, and “the court must define and explain the crime charged, setting* forth the essential elements thereof.” 23A C.J.S., Criminal Law, Section 1193.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit