Supreme Court of New Hampshire June 25, 1963, No. 5154 (Opinion of the Justices)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-06-1963
*23The following answer was returned:
To the Honorable Senate:
The undersigned Justices of the Supreme Court submit the following answers to the questions contained in your resolution filed June 20, 1963, with reference to Senate Bill No. 55, entitled “An Act to increase the interest and dividends tax exemption.” The bill would amend RSA 77:5 to provide that persons sixty-five years of age or over would be entitled to an additional exemption of four hundred dollars on their interest and dividends income taxable under RSA ch. 77.
Your first inquiry is whether “any constitutional provisions [of the New Hampshire Constitution would] be violated by providing for an additional exemption from the taxation of income as provided in SB 55.” It is our opinion that the bill if enacted would not be in violation of the state Constitution.
The interest and dividends tax from its inception has allowed an exemption (Laws 1923, c. 65, 5-. 2) and since 1951 the exemption has been $600. RSA 77:5; Laws 1951, c. 222, s. 1. While any exemption produces a theoretical inequality in the tax burden, it is recognized that the legislative power to tax is usually based on the proposition “that the equality sought is a practical one.” Opinion of the Justices, 82 N. H. 561, 570. *24The power of the Legislature to grant a reasonable exemption in the interest and dividends tax is not doubtful. Conner v. State, 82 N. H. 126, 128; Opinion of the Justices, 81 N. H. 563, 564; Sagendorph v. Marvin, 101 N. H. 79, 81.
The pending bill proposes to grant an additional exemption of $400 from the interest and dividends income to those persons who are sixty-five years or older. “In the selective process of classifying certain property for taxation and exempting other property the Legislature has a wide discretion which will be sustained ‘providing just reasons exist for the selection made.’” Opinion of the Justices, 95 N. H. 548, 550.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit