United States Customs Court August 19, 1963, C.D. 2408 (A. N. Deringer, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-08-1963

lead-opinion

DoNLON, Judge:

The issue here, succinctly stated, is whether additional duties, under section 304(c), Tariff Act of 1930, as amended, on imported sewing machine attachments not marked to show that Japan was the country of origin, are to be remitted. Plaintiff contends it is not liable for marking duties because the collector failed to give plaintiff a notice, customs Form 4647, to surrender the merchandise.

The merchandise was entered as American goods returned and was released prior to entry. Sometime later it was established that the merchandise actually was of Japanese origin.

Plaintiff’s position seems to be that there is no liability to marking duties on merchandise which has been released from customs custody, unless and until the collector has first demanded redelivery of the merchandise for legal marking or for export or destruction under customs supervision on the form prescribed pursuant to section 11.11 of the Customs Regulations. (19 CFR 11.11.)

In its protest, plaintiff also claimed that “the merchandise should be exempted from the requirements of marking under Sec. 304(a) (3) (F) or Sec. 304(a) (3) (H).” However, the claim for marking exemption is not argued. Indeed, no evidence was introduced on trial in support of that claim. Therefore, we deem that the claim to marking exemption has been abandoned, and it is overruled.

The facts are not in dispute. As adduced on trial, they are substantially as follows:

Certain sewing machine attachments were imported from Canada at Champlain, N.Y., and were entered on March 26, 1957, by A. N. Deringer, Inc., plaintiff herein, for account of Arrow Sewing Machine Co., Inc., Atlanta, Ga. The entry papers, which are of record, show that the merchandise was entered as a product of the United States, claimed to be duty free as American goods returned, under paragraph 1615, Tariff Act of 1930, as amended. Form No. 129, Foreign Service, signed by Arrow Sewing Machine Co., Ltd.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.