Wisconsin Supreme Court October 25, 1963 (State ex rel. State Bar v. Keller)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-10-1963

Per Curiam.

We have, as required by the order of the supreme court of the United States, reconsidered this matter in the light of Sperry v. Florida. 1 We said in our original opinion that the interstate commerce commission (p. 387), “can no more authorize persons unlicensed in this state to practice law here than could the public service commission of Wisconsin.” To the extent that such statement is' inconsistent with Sperry, it is withdrawn.

Sperry was registered to practice before the United States Patent Office but was not admitted to the bar of Florida. The supreme court of Florida enjoined Sperry from certain activities with respect to patent matters and from otherwise engaging in the practice of law in Florida. The supreme court of the United States determined that although the preparation and prosecution of patent applications for others constitute the practice of law and could, in the absence of federal statutes, be regulated by the states, the federal statutes permit the commissioner of patents to authorize nonlawyers to practice before the patent office. The commissioner has done so and the state’s control over the practice of law within its borders must yield (p. 402), “to the limited extent necessary for the accomplishment of the fed*102eral objectives.” The order of the supreme court of Florida was vacated since it prohibited Sperry (p. 404), “from performing tasks which are incident to the preparation and prosecution of patent applications before the Patent Office.”

The court said, however (p. 402) :

“Because of the breadth of the injunction issued in this case, we are not called upon to determine what functions are reasonably within the scope of the practice authorized by the Patent Office. The Commissioner has issued no regulations touching upon this point.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.