High Court of American Samoa September 12, 1963, No. 82-1963 (Tuanaitau v. Paogofie)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-09-1963

OPINION OF THE COURT

MORROW, Chief Justice.

Sasa’e Paogofie filed his application with the Registrar of Titles to have certain land designated by him as Faa*377toaga Fou registered as his individually-owned land. The application was accompanied by a survey of the land proposed to be registered. The survey showed that the area of the land is 8.35 ± acres.

Ropati Timuiala filed an objection to the proposed registration claiming that the land involved was the communal family land of the Timuiala Family. Tuanaitau filed a similar objection claiming that the same land was the communal family land of the Tuanaitau Family. Hence, this litigation. See Sec. 10.0112, Code of American Samoa, 1961 Ed. The Court viewed the land in the presence of Ropati and Paogofie and some others on the day preceding the hearing.

At the beginning of the hearing, Tuanaitau withdrew his objection and was dismissed as a party in the case.

The land involved in this case is attached to the Village of Iliili.

To establish his claim to the land, Paogofie, who is 52 years old, in substance testified that while he was born on the Island of Aunu’u, he was nevertheless brought to Iliili when he was about six years of age and that he lived in the Muli Family there. He also testified that when he was a boy only fifteen years of age he hired about half a dozen young men, all older than himself, ranging in age from 17 years to 22 years, some possibly older, and that he and these young men then proceeded to clear the land from the virgin bush. Paogofie testified that they would work possibly a couple of days a week and then not for two weeks and that the clearing was finished in 1929, and that then he put in plantations on the cleared land. This part of Paogofie’s testimony was corroborated by Tia and Leota, who testified that they worked with Paogofie in clearing the bush.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.