Supreme Court of Puerto Rico January 31, 1963, No. 381 (Montes v. State Insurance Fund)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-01-1963
Mr. Justice Dávila
delivered the opinion of the Court.
While working for his employer, a laborer, 57 years of age, married, and in good health, felt a strong pain in his waist, hips and thighs, fainted and fell to the floor. Taken to the State Insurance Fund he was submitted to physiotherapy and was discharged on August 11, 1953. The Fund believed that he needed no more treatment and that he could work again. He appealed to the Industrial Commission. After clinical examinations and other proper procedures, the Commission ordered by decision of November 30, 1954 that the case be referred again to the Fund “. . . in order to submit him to new X-ray and mielographic studies to eliminate the possibility of an intervertebral disk hernia ...” The Fund ordered the confinement of plaintiff in its Medico-Surgical Center with the following instruction:
*189“The above-mentioned laborer is referred for admission and neurological, X-ray, and mielographic studies by Dr. N. Rifkin-son, pursuant to the order of the Industrial Commission. Diagnosis: Contusion in the right thigh. The X-ray showed no os-seous pathology.”
Hospitalized on December 28, 1954, he was submitted to examination between that date and February 17, 1955. On February 19, 1955, Dr. Rifkinson submitted a report to the State Insurance Fund recommending that the patient be operated of a multiple herniation of the pulpous nucleus. The laborer returned to his home while the Fund decided about his operation.
On February 24 the Fund decided in favor of the operation and the patient’s hospitalization was ordered for the following March 7.
He was operated on March 15, 1955. Three vertebral disks in the lumbar region were removed. After the operation and apparently as a result thereof, paraplegy set on. He lacks the power of locomotion and must move on a wheelchair. He lost his sexual potency and has difficulty in evacuating and urinating, suffering from intense physical pain when doing so.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit