Supreme Court of Puerto Rico June 27, 1963, No. G-62-3 (Cordero Crespo v. Registrar of Property of Arecibo)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-1963

Mr. Justice Belaval

delivered the opinion of the Court.

On May 9, 1961, Rosa Crespo Hernández, married to Pedro Cordero Jiménez who at the time of adjudication was insane, executed a deed of satisfaction in favor of her son, Noel Cordero Crespo, petitioner herein, setting forth among the recitals in the deed that she and her husband, Pedro Cordero Jiménez, had acquired many years ago a two-story house past Calle Nueva in the ward of San Felipe of Arecibo, and that since her husband became incapacitated they were not able to make the necessary repairs and the house was in ruins, it being necessary for the other appearing party, her son Noel Cordero Crespo, to reconstruct the house, destroying practically the entire old structure and reconstructing it at a cost of $9,000; that it having been impossible for the executing party to pay for such investment, by deed of satisfaction No. 43 executed on May 9,1961, before Notary Efraín Ramírez Ramírez, Rosa Crespo Hernández assigned in satisfaction all her rights and actions in the lot and reconstructed house to Noel Cordero Crespo for the sum of $4,600.

The deed having been presented for registration, the Registrar of Property of Arecibo refused to record on the ground that, since the property was community property, her husband, Pedro Cordero Jiménez, had not given his consent for the giving in payment. The Registrar relied on the prohibition of § 91 of the Civil Code of Puerto Rico (1930) which provides: “Nevertheless the real property belonging to the conjugal community may not be alienated or burdened, such a transaction being null, except when effected with the mutual consent of both parties to the marriage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.