District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania March 21, 1963, No. 30661 (Dietrich v. Standard Brands, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1963

FREEDMAN, District Judge.

Plaintiff in this action for copyright infringement has moved for summary judgment under Rule 56.

Plaintiff is the holder by assignment of the copyright on certain slide rule calculators. They are used chiefly by retail grocers to determine quickly a price based on cost and a desired markup. Some time in May 1958 defendant purchased a quantity of calculators from Whitehead & Hoag Company, a manufacturer of such articles, and distributed them free of charge to retail grocers as an advertisement of defendant’s “Tender Leaf Tea”. If there was any infringement, it was the fault of Whitehead & Hoag Company, the manufacturer. But Whitehead & Hoag Company was dissolved in December 1959 following the sale of all its assets to another company. Hence the suit, which was brought in December 1961, is against the defendant as an innocent infringer*.

It is strenuously urged by plaintiff that there are no material issues of fact to be tried and that the questions of law which alone remain should be decided by the court on the motion for summary judgment.

We may not, of course, determine issues of fact because they appear to us to preponderate so heavily in favor of the plaintiff that we would have no hesitation in accepting the plaintiff’s claim if we were called upon to decide the facts. A careful study of the record leads to the inescapable conclusion that a number of factual issues are in dispute. Summary judgment therefore is not appropriate.

1. There is a presumption of the validity of plaintiff’s copyright. This presumption is supported by the allegation in the Complaint (¶[5) that plaintiff’s calculator is copyrightable and contains “a large amount of material wholly original with the author”. The Answer, however, denies that the material is copyrightable and puts in issue the averment that the work contains original material. The pleadings thus raise an issue of fact on originality. Moreover, defendant’s answer to interrogatory no.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.