District Court, N.D. Ohio May 8, 1963, Civ. A. No. C 62-899 (Aerojet-General Corp. v. Aero-Jet Products Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-05-1963
KALBFLEISCH, District Judge.
Plaintiff, Aerojet-General Corporation, has brought this action, based upon an alleged violation of its trademark, against Aero-Jet Products Corporation and Plasti-Kote, Inc. Defendants have filed a counterclaim charging a violation of the Sherman Act by the plaintiff and the General Tire and Rubber Company, of which the plaintiff is a wholly-owned subsidiary. And, among other defenses to the plaintiff’s petition, the defendants have raised the contention that the plaintiff. is barred from recovery because of the equitable doctrine of unclean hands. This defense is based upon the same alleged violation of the Sherman Act as the counterclaim. Aerojet-General Corporation has moved to strike the defense of unclean hands and to dismiss the counterclaim, and has opposed the motion to make the General Tire and Rubber Company a defendant to the counterclaim.
In sections of its brief Aerojet-General Corporation professes to be unable to understand the nature of the defense and counterclaim. The Court finds no such difficulty.
Defendants claim that the General Tire and Rubber Company is in coinpetition with the defendants, although they do not allege that AerojetGeneral Corporation is in such competition. The counterclaim alleges that the General Tire and Rubber Company entered into a conspiracy with its subsidiai'y, Aerojet-General Corporation, whereby Aerojet-General Corporation would use its trademark for the purpose of hindering the defendants in their competition with the General Tire and Rubber Company. The counterclaim further alleges that this conspiracy and the actions taken in pursuance of it are in violation of the Sherman Act, and to the public detriment, and therefore the defendants are entitled to treble damages. The defense of unclean hands is based upon similar allegations.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit