District Court, W.D. Texas September 19, 1963, Civ. A. No. 3080 (United States v. San Antonio Portland Cement Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-09-1963
SPEARS, Chief Judge.
This suit was brought by the Government against the defendant taxpayer to recover an allegedly erroneous refund of more than one million dollars of Federal income tax covering the taxable years 1953 through 1956.
The motion presently before the Court was filed by the defendant under Rule 34, F.R.Civ.P., to require the Government to produce certain intra-office reports, memoranda, or other documents of the Internal Revenue Service, for inspection and copying.
During the four years involved, the defendant was engaged in the business of mining limestone cement rock from a quarry which it owns, manufacturing Portland cement from said limestone cement rock, and selling the Portland cement.
In computing its taxable income for each of the four years, the defendant was allowed a deduction of percentage depletion as a percentage of its gross income from sales of manufactured Portland cement.
At the time the refund was approved, the Cannelton1 case was pending before the United States Supreme Court. In its decision subsequently rendered, that Court held that the percentage depletion allowance should be based on the value of the limestone rock as mined from the quarry, and not on the higher amount realized after the rock had been manufactured and sold as cement.
As a consequence, the Government now contends that the amount of percentage depletion should have been determined by this taxpayer as a percentage of gross income from the mining of limestone cement rock, as if the taxpayer were selling limestone cement rock mined from its quarry to itself for fabrication into Portland cement, rather than on the basis of its gross income from sales of manufactured cement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit