Massachusetts District Court, Appellate Division July 1, 1963, No. 23167 (Clyde Everett Equipment Co. v. Brockton Perforating Machine Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1963

Murphy, J.

This case came to us on a report established by the Appellate Division.

This is an action of contract, in which the plaintiff alleges that the defendant owes the sum of $194.08 for repairs to a bulldozer made on September 29, 1959. The answer is general denial, payment, denial of agency and that the plaintiff is not qualified to do business in Massachusetts, and therefore precluded from maintaining the action. The court found for the defendant.

At the trial the defendant stated in open .court that the labor and materials were furnished by the plaintiff to the defendant and that there was no dispute as to price, that it waived any defense of agency and also waived the allegation in its answer that the plaintiff was not qualified to do business in Massachusetts. The only question the defendant raised was that of payment, claiming that the parties agreed that the plaintiff was to share the cost of any and all repairs made to the bulldozer on a fifty-fifty basis.

There was evidence to show that on May 27, 1959 the defendant purchased from the plaintiff a used, as is, International TB-9 *68Crawler Tractor with Bucryurus Erie Dozer shovel for $3200.00 plus trucking. At that time a written agreement was executed.

The court made special findings in part as follows:

"The defendant purchased a used bulldozer from the plaintiff for $3200.00, prior to the purchase the parties hereto agreed that the cost of any repairs made to the bulldozer were to be pro rated between said parties on a fifty-fifty basis.

Upon two separate occasions, not including the claim made in this action, the plaintiff made repairs and accepted as payment one-half of the charges made for labor and materials or parts furnished.

In the present instance the plaintiff made reparis and furnished parts in the amount of $388.16, pursuant to the agreement between the parties the defendant paid the plaintiff the sum of $194.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.