Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Delaware County April 24, 1963, no. 1484 (Pantano v. Merrick)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-04-1963
Sweney, P. J.,
Michael Anthony Homes, Inc., subdivided a previously undeveloped parcel of ground and erected a number of single-family dwellings thereon. Plaintiffs became the owners of the premises known as no. 186 Hillside Circle, Villanova, Pa., by deed dated December 12, 1955. Defendant became the owner of the adjoining premises known as no. 184 Hillside Circle by deed dated December 20, 1955. When plaintiffs made settlement for their property, the driveway for no. 184 Hillside Circle was not completed. In June, 1956, plaintiffs had a survey made in preparation for fencing their property and learned for the first time that part of defendant’s driveway was located on their property. Thereafter, they notified defendant of the encroachment and requested that the encroaching portion of the driveway be removed.
There is no dispute of the fact that the driveway of defendant encroaches upon plaintiffs’ property for a distance in length of 70 feet and a width varying from 1 foot at the southern end to approximately 5 feet at the northern end of said driveway. The only issue before us is whether defendant has sustained his contention that he acquired an easement by implication to use a portion of plaintiffs’ property for part of his driveway.
Implied easements are not favored in the law. The burden is upon the party claiming such an easement *295to establish by clear proof all the necessary elements: Becker v. Rittenhouse 297 Pa. 317, 325 (1929). We are convinced that defendant has failed to prove his claim to an easement by implication.
Our Supreme Court in Baptist Church in the Great Valley v. Urquhart 406 Pa. 620 (1962), set forth the elements necessary to establish an easement by implication. In that case the court, quoting from Spaeder v. Tabak, 170 Pa. Superior Ct.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit