Supreme Court of Oklahoma April 7, 1964, 40854 (State Ex Rel. Evertson v. Cornett)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-04-1964
JACKSON, Justice.
This original action for writ of mandamus presents a question of first impression
*279
in this state as to whether a trial court in a divorce proceeding has judicial power to order blood tests for a child whose paternity is questioned.
It arose out of a case- in which the wife sued the husband for divorce. The petition alleged, among other things, that the parties had been married since 1951 and that one child had been bora of the marriage. This child was about 8 months old when the petition was filed in July, 1963. The wife prayed for a divorce, alimony, the custody of the child and child support money. The answer of the defendant husband admitted the marriage but denied that he was the father of the child; he also filed a cross petition in which he asked for a divorce.
Thereafter the husband filed a “Motion to Require Blood Test” in which he recited, in effect, that the child had been bom in lawful wedlock, but that he was not the father; that under such circumstances there is a strong presumption of law that the child is the legitimate child of the husband and wife, and that strong and convincing evidence is necessary to overcome this presumption of legitimacy. He alleged that such evidence could be obtained through blood grouping tests and that “it has now been scientifically determined that it can be established by blood tests of the child, the mother, and the alleged father, that the alleged father is
not
the father of the child; that such scientific proof is certain, positive and conclusive” (emphasis supplied). He offered to submit to such a test himself and asked the court to order the wife to submit herself and the child to the tests, at the hands of a qualified expert to be appointed by the court, such test to be made “in the presence of the plaintiff and defendant or their authorized representatives”.
At the hearing on this motion, defendant husband offered the deposition of Dr. C.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit