Oregon Supreme Court December 16, 1964 (Twilleager v. North American Accident Ins.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-1964

*258

ROSSMAN J.

This is an appeal by the plaintiff from a judgment which the circuit court entered in favor of the defendant after a jury had returned a verdict for the plaintiff. The court entered judgment for the defendant notwithstanding the verdict: see ORS 18.140 (2). This appeal challenges the judgment thus entered.

The action is based upon a policy of health and accident insurance which the defendant issued to the plaintiff January 21, 1958. The policy was in full force .and offect at all times material to this case. By the terms of the policy defendant agreed to pay stated sums of money to the plaintiff by way of indemnity for either total or partial disability, suffered as a result of accidental injury, and which prevented the plaintiff from carrying out his duties as a custodian’s helper at Portland’s Jefferson High School.

While operating an automobile on January 18,1962, plaintiff was involved in an accident as a result of which he sustained, inter alia, an injury to his left knee. Defendant paid to plaintiff, or tendered into court, sums intended to satisfy the full amount of benefits for partial disability provided in the policy. Plaintiff contended that he was totally disabled and brought this action to recover the larger benefits provided therefor.

The only assignment of error challenges the propriety of the trial court’s order which granted judgment notwithstanding the verdict. The only issue at trial was whether the plaintiff was entitled to benefits for total disability as that condition is defined in the policy. The issue before us is whether there was substantial evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, sufficient to establish that the injury

*259

to plaintiff’s left knee was such as to totally disable plaintiff from engaging in “any and every ldnd of business or labor pertaining to his occupation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.