Supreme Court of New Jersey November 16, 1964 (Hodes Ex Rel. Kalb v. Oak Flooring Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1964

The opinion of the court was delivered by

SchettiNO, J.

Petitioner (hereinafter plaintiff) obtained a judgment against Oak Flooring Co. (hereinafter defendant) in the Workmen’s Compensation Division. Defendant filed a notice of appeal to the Union County Court with the Workmen’s Compensation Division at Trenton on the 45th day after the compensation judgment was filed in the Division, but did not file its notice of appeal with the Clerk of Union County until the 46th day.

Plaintiff moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the late filing of the notice with the County Clerk was contrary to

N. J. 8. A.

34:15-66 which provides for the filing within 45 days. Defendant made a cross motion in which it sought an order enlarging the time within which the appeal might be taken pursuant to the provisions of

B. R.

1:27B, or, in the alternative, a

nunc pro tunc

order in the event that the court determined that the notice of appeal previously filed had not been filed within time. The County Court granted plaintiff’s motion, holding that it had no power to relax the filing time requirement, and denied defendant’s cross motion. The Appellate Division affirmed, 82

N. J. Super.

216 (1964). Thereafter, we granted certification on defendant’s petition. 42

N. J.

140 (1964).

*362

The facts are not in dispute. Defendant’s attorney “in charge of handling this appeal” was directed on Friday, June 7, 1963 to prosecute an appeal, and was advised that if an appeal was to be taken, the notice had to be filed by Monday, June 10, 1963. The notice of appeal was dictated that Friday afternoon with instructions to type the notice on Monday morning and have it hand-delivered to and filed with the Division in Trenton and the County Clerk’s office in Union County on that day. Defendant’s attorney could not personally supervise the matter since he had on Monday, June 10, learned of his father’s death and had left for Florida to attend the funeral.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.