Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) March 20, 1964 (Green v. Asher Coal Mining Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-03-1964

CLAY, Commissioner.

This controversy involves the liability of the owner of land leased for strip mining: purposes to a lower riparian owner allegedly" damaged by debris produced in the strip mining operation. The trial court dismissed' appellant plaintiffs’ complaint on the ground it failed to state a claim.

The complaint alleges in substance the following facts. Appellee defendant is engaged in the business of purchasing, leasing and developing lands for the purpose of carrying on mining operations. It leased some of its land to be mined for coal and the lessee adopted the method of strip mining. Defendant “was fully cognizant and aware of the nature of the mining operation thus to be conducted”. The mining operation resulted in the displacement of top soil, rock, shale and other types of strata. After the cessation of the strip mining operation the defendant did not restore the land to prevent soil erosion or excessive drainage along natural water courses. As a result of the condition created, following a heavy rainfall vast quantities of loose rock, dirt and coal were washed down the mountainside, obstructing natural water courses, causing the flooding of plaintiffs’ premises, and depositing debris thereon, thereby injuring plaintiffs’ land.

It is alleged defendant failed to exercise ordinary care in the use of its property and was guilty of wanton, reckless and wilful conduct. Punitive as well as compensatory damages were demanded.

The complaint (which we commend as a model pleading) very thoroughly states a basic cause of action. The important, difficult and narrow question is whether it states a claim against the defendant landowner. It is the position of the defendant that the wrongful acts complained of were committed by its lessee and it is not liable therefor. It cannot be disputed that as a general rule the landlord is not liable for the negligent acts of his tenant. 32 Am. Jut., Landlord and Tenant, sections 161,

*70

817; Farmer v. Modern Motors Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.