District Court of Appeal of Florida June 9, 1964, 63-617 (Park v. Belford Trucking Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1964

165 So.2d 819 (1964) Annie Mae PARK, a Widow, Appellant, v. BELFORD TRUCKING CO., Inc., et al., Appellees. No. 63-617. District Court of Appeal of Florida. Third District. June 9, 1964. Rehearing Denied July 20, 1964. *820 Fuller & Brumer, Kenneth L. Ryskamp, Miami, for appellant. Wakefield & Underwood, Scott, McCarthy, Preston & Steel and Phillip Goldman, Miami, for appellees. Before CARROLL, HORTON and HENDRY, JJ. HENDRY, Judge. Plaintiff instituted two actions, one under the wrongful death act,[1] and the other as administratrix of the estate of her husband under the survival statute.[2] The actions were consolidated and tried before a jury which returned a verdict of $104,500 on the first cause of action and $5,000 on the second. The defendant's motion for a new trial as to both actions, was granted as to the first, on damages only, and denied as to the second. The plaintiff appeals the order granting a new trial, for the determination of damages only. *821 Although we may only consider those grounds specified by the trial judge in granting the motion for new trial,[3] it will be necessary for us to set forth the judge's order in its entirety: "AFTER DUE NOTICE to the parties, this cause came on to be heard before me on the post-trial motions of the defendants, including a motion for new trial or in the alternative for a remittitur. The Court has heard argument of counsel and being otherwise duly advised in the premises, finds that a new trial must be granted solely on the issue of damages. The Court further finds that in all other respects defendants' post trial motion should be denied. "The Court has deliberated on this matter for many months and concludes that the verdict in the amount of $104,520 for the plaintiff is grossly excessive, without foundation in the evidence, and is shamefully shocking to the Court's judicial conscience.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.