Michigan Supreme Court April 6, 1964, Calendar 26, Docket 50,284 (Nickola v. United Commercial Travellers of America)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-04-1964
combined-opinion
372 Mich. 600 (1964) 127 N.W.2d 309 NICKOLA v. UNITED COMMERCIAL TRAVELLERS OF AMERICA. Calendar No. 26, Docket No. 50,284. Supreme Court of Michigan. Decided April 6, 1964. Sherman M. Bean and Philip Elliott, for plaintiff. Gault, Davison & Bowers (Matthew Davison, Jr., of counsel), for defendant. *601 O'HARA, J. Tried to the court without a jury was the issue of plaintiff's entitlement to the death benefits under 4 accident insurance policies with a total face value of $16,500. Our scope of review is limited: (1) Was there competent evidence to sustain the trial judge's finding of fact? (2) Was such finding of fact against the great weight of the evidence ? (3) Was any error of law committed? Plaintiff's insured as above indicated, on March 6, 1959, while pushing his car slipped and fell. This happened about 8:30 a.m. His wife witnessed the fall. Being apprehensive of the result, she went to his office about 9 a.m. the same morning and found him lying on a couch in apparent pain and distress. He refused, at that time, medical attention. At about 3 p.m. she returned to the office to find him hemorrhaging. She prevailed upon him to go to the doctor's office. Upon his return he was stilling bleeding internally and urinating blood. Subsequent medical examination revealed a tumor on the bladder. He was hospitalized to control the bleeding. March 8th, his condition was diagnosed as carcinoma of the bladder. On March 9th, the first of a 2-stage operation was performed. The second stage could not be completed because of uncontrollable bleeding. This required a change in operational procedure and the whole tumor, or most of it, was then removed. The insured survived the operative procedures and his condition was post operatively satisfactory. On March 16th, he died. The immediate cause was given as a coronary occlusion resulting from a pulmonary embolism.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit