District of Columbia Court of Appeals March 30, 1964, 3355 (Congressional Insurance Co. v. Ford Motor Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1964

QUINN, Associate Judge.

Appellant, subrogee of Joseph Henry Wood, sought recovery for a loss sustained by Wood when his automobile was destroyed by fire. Appellee filed a third-party complaint against the dealer, Triangle Motors. At the close of appellant’s case, the court entered a trial finding in favor of appellee and Triangle Motors. The sole ■question on appeal is whether appellant established a prima facie case.

The facts are as follows: On October 5, 1961, Wood purchased a new Ford automobile from Triangle Motors. On January 11, 1962, as was his usual practice on cold -mornings, he started the engine while the ■car was parked in the driveway of his home. 'He then went inside to drink a cup of .coffee, and a few minutes later he saw a -man run into his yard. "\Vood opened the front door and discovered his car engulfed -in flames. He immediately called the fire ■ department. After the fire was extinguished the car was towed to Triangle Motors.

Wood testified that Triangle Motors serviced the car prior to delivery. Thereafter "he had occasion to check the tires and lights, "look under the hood, and have the mechanics at the gas station check the oil. At the time of the fire the car had been driven between 5,000 and 6,000 miles. Wood stated that .there were only two occasions when any work had been done on the engine. The first occurred when a service station replaced the standard oil filter with which the car was equipped. The second occurred when he noticed the smell of gas shortly after purchasing the car. His own inspection disclosed that the gasoline filter bowl was leaking and he was able to tighten it with his fingers.

George David, one of Triangle’s mechanics, testified that after the fire the car remained in the shop for some period of time but was not worked on or touched by anyone. During this period the car was inspected by an appraiser.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.