Supreme Court of New Hampshire March 3, 1964, 5185 (Manning v. Freeman)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-03-1964
Wheeler, J.
On May 27, 1960 (the day of the accident) the plaintiff Janice, twenty-two months old, and the youngest of six children, resided with her mother in her grandmother’s apartment which was located on the third floor of a three-story building, on the right, looking toward the rear of the building.
The second and third floors each had two apartments leading on to rear porches which had a railing around the outside. The stairway to the second floor descended from a point about midway of the porch and the stairwell was surrounded, except for the head of the stairs by a railing.
A side railing consisting of a handrail and a four and three-quarter inch guardrail extended the length of the stairway from the second to the third floors parallel to the incline thereof supported by a vertical post about midway between the floors. There were twelve steps and thirteen risers on the stairway. The right descending guardrail was fastened to the stairwell support timber at a point vertically over the edge of the third stair from the top. There was an open space on the outside edge of each stair which measured nine inches vertically from the nose of the tread to the bottom of the guardrail and sixteen inches vertically from the rear of the tread to the guardrail.
On the morning of the accident Mrs. Manning put Janice and her brother Michael aged four out to play on the third floor porch. Two kitchen chairs were placed on their sides with their legs facing each other at the head of the stairs. After remaining on the porch for a while she returned to her apartment. From time to time she and her mother glanced out of the window to observe the children. At 11:30 A. M. Mrs. Manning heard screams and upon reaching the porch saw Janice lying on the ground. Her sister Linda who had just returned from school was beside her.
The chairs at the top of the stairs had been moved and one was “pushed over.” When Mrs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit