Court of Appeals of Tennessee July 10, 1964 (Davis v. Anthony)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-07-1964

McAMIS, P J.

This case involves the construction of the separate wills of M. L. Tipton and his wife, Helen A. Tipton, both of whom died when their private plane

*497

crashed November 2, 1962. The wills, both dated May 25, 1961, were duly probated in common form.

’ Mrs. Margaret M. Davis, a legatee under the will of M. L. Tipton, filed her original bill on January 18, 1963, seeking a construction of both wills and declaratory judgment settling the rights of all parties. On January 21, 1963, John W. Anthony and K. Gr. Sherrod, the named executors under both wills, filed their original bill also seeking a declaratory decree. The two eases were later consolidated and tried as one suit.

Both M. L. Tipton and Helen A. Tipton left very substantial estates. Neither had any living descendants. Each devised to the other fifty per cent of their respective estates, the remaining fifty per cent, after payment of inheritance and estate taxes, to go to numerous designated legatees.

It is conceded that the testator and testatrix met death in a common disaster and died simultaneously, with the result that, under the Simultaneous Death Statute, T.C.A. sec. 31-501 et seq., the gift of each to the other lapsed. The principal question is whether the property which would otherwise have gone under the wills to the respective spouses passed under the wills to the legatees or passed to the heirs at law under the laws of descent and distribution.

The form and purport of the two wills are in substance and effect identical, the only material difference being the names of the legatees. We quote the pertinent portions of the will of M. L. Tipton:

“FIRST: I hereby nominate and appoint John W. Anthony. K. Gr. Sherrod, and my wife, Helen A. Tipton, as executors and excuse them from giving bond and from

*498

making any report or settlement with, any eonrt or other authority.

“SECOND: I direct that all my lawful debts and funeral expenses be paid as soon as convenient after my death.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.