Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) March 13, 1964 (Higbee v. Thomas)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-03-1964

PALMORE, Judge.

In October of 1960 the appellant, David Higbee, pleaded guilty to an indictment in the Hopkins Circuit Court charging him with incest and was sentenced to 21 years in prison. KRS 436.060. He was committed to the penitentiary at Eddyville and in May of 1962 filed in the Lyon Circuit Court a petition for habeas corpus based on sworn allegations to the following effect:

(1) On the date of the trial in circuit court "counsel for the defense spent approximately three to five minutes with defendant prior to his assignment and therefore your petitioner did not and could not have a reasonable length of time to make, prepare and present an adequate defense * * * all of which denied to your peti

*306

tioner effective ‘assistance of counsel for liis defense,’ ” etc.

(2) After “the approximate three to five ■minute conference with said court appointed counsel who dominatedly insisted on entering a ‘plea of guilty,’ and further your ■petitioner being overwhelmed by both court .and aforesaid counsel also being deceived ,by an oral statement from the Hopkins ■County Sheriff to your petitioner’s wife in ■words to the effect that if Dave (meaning •me — the petitioner) will plead guilty, he won’t get over two to five years, and therefore your petitioner being deceived and under duress and coercion made the plea to .the court but not of his own free will.”

(3) The prosecuting witnesses, Betty L. Higbee and Rowena Higbee, had demanded withdrawal of the incest charge in October of 1960.

The Lyon Circuit Court sustained the Commonwealth’s motion to dismiss the petition for habeas corpus on the ground it did not state facts upon which relief could be granted. Higbee then appealed to this court in forma pauperis. Our decision affirming the dismissal was expressed as follows in a memorandum opinion written by Judge Moremen:

“(1) The broad allegation contained under this item is not sufficient to cause the writ to issue.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.