Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit April 17, 1964, 19026_1 (Greenfield State Bank v. Franklin Kyle Copeland)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-04-1964
BARNES, Circuit Judge:
This is an appeal from an order of the United States District Court affirming the order of a referee in bankruptcy which overruled appellant’s objections to the discharge of the bankrupt, Franklin Kyle Copeland.
Jurisdiction existed below (§§ 2, sub. a(10) and 2, sub. a(12), Bankruptcy Act
*768
of 1938, Title 11 United States Code, §§ 11, sub. a(10) and 11, sub. a(12)) and here (§ 24, Bankruptcy Act of 1938, Title 11 United States Code, § 47).
The basis of appellant’s objections to the bankrupt’s discharge was the alleged fact the bankrupt had obtained a loan from appellant amounting to $3,000 by filing a false and fraudulent financial-statement.
There is no question but that the bank loaned Copeland $3,000. In connection with such loan, it is undisputed Copeland furnished his financial statement to the bank, dated January 4,1962. The factual dispute is when each of these acts were accomplished. The referee found this statement was in fact false, but also found the bank could not have relied on the false statement in making the loan. The district court ruled there was substantial evidence to support the finding -of the referee, and affirmed the order.
Appellant bank urges there was “a total failure of any substantial evidence” to support this finding; that the fact of non-reliance “is contradicted by
almost
every single bit of evidence in this case.” (Emphasis added.)
The referee, of course, filed his certificate and report when the district judge was called upon to review the referee’s order overruling the bank’s objections to discharge. His summary of the evidence is before us (Clk’s Tr. pp. 16-21).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit